Guide
Strategy
Brands
An open affiliate program lets anyone who applies sign up and start promoting immediately; an application-only (curated) program requires the brand to approve each affiliate before they get access to products and tracking links. The choice trades reach and speed against brand-safety control — and most brands end up with a hybrid, requiring approval only for the most visible or highest-commission part of the program.
An open affiliate program (open enrollment) lets anyone who meets the broadest possible bar — usually just creating an account — sign themselves up and get immediate access to a tracking link, discount codes and promotional material. No one at the brand looks at an individual application before access is granted. An application-only program (also called curated or invitation-only) requires the brand to actively approve every profile before it gets access — whether the creator applied themselves or the brand reached out first.
That's a different decision from the setup type — whether the program runs on an open network, an app inside your own store, or a platform-managed solution — covered in how to set up an affiliate program, step by step. You can run an application-only program on an open network (the network just handles the sign-up flow while you approve manually), or a fully open program through a platform-managed setup. Setup type is about where the program runs technically; open-vs-application-only is about who gets let in.
| Open program | Application-only program | |
|---|---|---|
| Reach and speed | High — anyone can join immediately, no bottleneck | Lower — limited by how fast the brand can review applications |
| Brand-safety control | Low before sign-up — problems surface only after an affiliate is already promoting | High before sign-up — you see the profile before it gets access |
| Admin burden | Low ongoing — the system largely runs itself | Higher — every application costs someone's time |
| Typical commission level | Often lower, because the program has to carry a broader, more uneven quality of affiliate | Can often be higher, because each affiliate has been assessed as a genuine fit |
| Best suited to | Large, low-risk product categories and volume-driven programs | Visible brands, regulated products, ambassador deals and higher commission |
TikTok Shop's own Affiliate Program illustrates this trade-off directly, because TikTok itself offers both models side by side. As covered in TikTok Shop LIVE Shopping with influencers, a brand can list products for open collaboration, where any eligible affiliate creator can find and pick up the product themselves in TikTok Shop's Affiliate Marketplace without the brand doing anything — or for target collaboration, where the brand invites specific creators directly. A brand can run both at once: the bulk of the catalogue open, and the most visible or highest-commission products invitation-only.
The two models are the ends of a spectrum, not a binary choice. Most affiliate networks and apps let you set simple automatic approval rules — a minimum follower count, a minimum account age, or a geographic match, for example — so the large majority of applications clear automatically, and only the ones that fall outside the rules go to manual review. That captures most of the open model's speed without giving up all control. Check your own network's or app's documentation for exactly which rules can be automated — the specifics vary by provider.
Another common hybrid keeps sign-up itself open but puts the approval gate on payout: anyone can join and get a tracking link, but the first payout requires the brand to have approved the profile. That lets an affiliate start testing the program immediately, while the brand still gets a checkpoint before any money moves.
If you choose an application-only program, the real question is what the approval should actually screen for — and two checks the Academy already covers for individual influencer collaborations work just as well as approval criteria for an affiliate application. How to check an influencer's audience before you pay them covers whether an applicant's audience matches your market and is genuine — relevant because an affiliate with an inflated or poorly matched audience can still earn commission on sales you'd never have approved a paid deal for. A brand safety checklist for influencer partnerships covers whether an applicant's public conduct and content history is a risk to your brand — relevant because an affiliate typically posts under their own name with your products, the same as a paid influencer would. Both checklists can be used directly as a shorter application review, rather than inventing new criteria from scratch.
IF the product is low-risk, broad-market, and volume matters more than control → choose an open program.
IF the brand is regulated, highly visible, or sells a product where the wrong affiliate creates legal or reputational risk → choose an application-only program.
IF you don't have the resources for ongoing manual review → start open with automatic approval rules, and reserve manual review for the exceptions only.
IF you already run curated influencer relationships and just want to add a performance option → an application-only or invitation-only program fits best, because you've already done the selection work.
IF you want the best of both → keep the bulk of the catalogue open, and put an application or invitation gate on your most visible products and highest commission tiers.
The numbers below are hypothetical and for illustration only — not data from a Make Influence customer.
A brand launches a new affiliate program and compares the two models over the first month:
The open program produces more active affiliates in absolute terms (40 vs. 14) for zero admin time. The application-only program produces fewer, but far more predictable affiliates — and the 5 hours of review buys a checkpoint before any of the 20 got to use the brand's name and products. Which trade-off is the right one depends on how much a single bad affiliate can actually cost you — a figure this calculation doesn't include, but one that's usually the real deciding factor.
Make Influence doesn't run an open affiliate program. Our model is curated: the brand, or Make Influence on the brand's behalf, selects and briefs each individual profile in advance — in practice the same logic as a fully application-only program, just without an open sign-up flow at all. Our experience is that the time a brand spends assessing a profile before first contact is rarely wasted — it's almost always cheaper to say no before a deal than to clean up after one that shouldn't have been let in.
Yes, but be aware that already-enrolled affiliates typically keep their access unless you actively remove them — adding an approval layer going forward only affects new applicants. Re-vetting existing affiliates too requires a separate, explicit decision.
Yes. Without written criteria, approval decisions become inconsistent from one application to the next, and it becomes hard to explain a rejection if an applicant asks why. Use the two checklists linked above as a starting point.
Yes — TikTok Shop's own Affiliate Program offers both open collaboration (open) and target collaboration (invitation-only) side by side for the same brand. See TikTok Shop LIVE Shopping with influencers for the full mechanics.
Application-only in practice — though without an open sign-up flow at all, because we work in a curated way: the brand or Make Influence selects and briefs each profile in advance, rather than leaving a program open for free sign-up.
The technical setup takes the same amount of time regardless of model — see how to set up an affiliate program. What takes longer with an application-only program isn't the launch itself, but the ongoing review of applications once the program is live.
That's often a sensible hybrid. A small gifted-product affiliate arrangement carries low risk even if one profile turns out to be a poor fit. An ambassador deal with high visibility and high commission deserves the more thorough review an application-only flow provides.
Make Influence
Find creators with real audience data, run collaborations in one place, and see clicks and sales per creator while the campaign is live.
Book a demoCreate accountMake Influence
Apply to campaigns from brands that are actively looking, follow your own clicks and sales, and get paid without chasing invoices.
Create creator profileMore creator guidesMake Influence
Briefs, agreed terms, tracking links and results sit together — so brands and creators see the same numbers.
See how it worksBrowse the Academy
